My first musical experience was at my old Baptist church. As
some of you know there is usually a leader or a master conductor who is over
the band and choir. Well now I that I think about it, there was always a man
controlling that whole system. He was usually the piano player and he would
ALWAYS get the solos..always..no exaggeration. He would run the rehearsals,
told us what to wear, who had a solo (ha!) and what songs we were going to
sing. I never really payed attention to that until now because maybe when you
were 10 or 12, you never really payed attention to gender roles. I know I didn’t,
I was too busy worried about friends and boys.
As most of you know, I am a vocal performance major but I
also played the viola in high school. Before I wanted to play the viola I wanted
to play the drums but I had to play the xylophones first…no mam. So I decided
to play the viola. Majority of the boys played in band of course, the boys mostly
played brass instruments and very few played the percussion. As for the orchestra,
we only had one boy play the violin. When I started middle school I begin to
realize that boys were not playing in the orchestra because I had raging
hormones and there were no boys to look at! We only had like three boys out of
20-25 people. When I got in High school nothing seemed to change with the boy to
girl ratio. My senior year in High school, we only had about 6-8 boys out of 50
people playing in the orchestra.
I was also in chorus and of course we had more females than
males. I enjoyed being in a mix choir because it’s so nice hearing baritones
and tenors. Male singers have a different timbre so it’s really exciting to
hear something completely different. The males acted immature for the most part
when it came to learning music. However, they learned their music quicker than
the females. I did state chorus also and its like an audition for singers.
Being in State chorus kind of changed my life. I was in the
mixed chorus and there were more men than women. (score!) When we practiced a
piece of music we always split apart from the men and practiced. I remember one
rehearsal when the men came in and they finished before us. They performed
their solo part in a piece called Qui
Sedes. The tenors did their part towards the end of the song just by
themselves. I thought I died and went to Heaven because it was so beautiful!
Being at Converse, I now appreciate mixed choirs because I
am in Chorale and it’s all women with no men singing. I missed hearing low
notes from men or when the tenor section sings and it’s like “whoa..how can you
sing that high and you’re a man”. I feel like when men are in a choir they are stable
and they create such balance between women. It’s so hard to explain. But I enjoy being in
the chorale but sometimes I would like to hear and be around some testosterone.
These are some interesting comments, Sherami. As I've said on a number of other blogs, I'm continually surprised by how few boys play string instruments in this part of the country--it's not that way everywhere. And the Qui Sedes you link to is beautiful--are you sure it's the one your choir sang? There are so many settings of that text. In fact, there's a beautiful aria in the Bach B Minor Mass on the Qui Sedes text for voice and oboe d'amore.
ReplyDeleteOne thing that you pointed out that I have also noticed was that it does seem that men do get a lot of piano solos! Whether it be on television or a live performance that is held in town for instance, there are many men who play the piano and perform different pieces. Although from a church scene prospective, I noticed that women are mainly the ones who play the piano there so the gender roles vary depending on the type of setting and traditional background.
ReplyDeleteOne thing that you pointed out that I have also noticed was that it does seem that men do get a lot of piano solos! Whether it be on television or a live performance that is held in town for instance, there are many men who play the piano and perform different pieces. Although from a church scene prospective, I noticed that women are mainly the ones who play the piano there so the gender roles vary depending on the type of setting and traditional background.
ReplyDeleteHey Sherami
ReplyDeleteI miss male voices in choir, too, but I really appreciate all the harmonies that we can do in Chorale without them. In my church choir at home, there was a high school freshman boy who sang bass. He was often very immature and annoyingly talkative during rehearsal, until one night our choir director snapped and yelled at him. I have never heard a woman yell that loudly or angrily, or seen a boy so afraid, before or since. Well, he shaped up after that.
-Erin
I had a very different experience with my church choir (and choirs in general) and how it treats gender roles, so I found it interesting how you experienced this. Our church choir directors have been women my entire life, and the male priest we had when I was younger did not try to dictate what the choir director chose. Ironically (maybe), the male choir director I had in middle school was less controlling than my female choir directors, and, especially in middle school, the majority of solos went to the girls. Once we got to high school, there was a little more of an even split.
ReplyDeleteI'm still laughing at how you realized there were no boys... "raging hormones." That's great. That sucks that you were introduced to gender roles in the beginning of your life, but I'm glad they've escaped your brain.
ReplyDeleteI'm still laughing at how you realized there were no boys... "raging hormones." That's great. That sucks that you were introduced to gender roles in the beginning of your life, but I'm glad they've escaped your brain.
ReplyDeleteI'm dying over your "raging hormones" comment! And I have to say that I totally agree... I absolutely love the sound of men's voices in a choral setting. I have come to appreciate women's voices much more, and I am a proud alto two and can easily hang with the tenors!
ReplyDeleteMy church is the same way when it comes to men leading but I do remember at one point we did have a female choir director. Not sure what happened to her though. Mixed choirs are a lot more fun to listen to than all girls. I feel like you can do a little bit more with the mixed choirs.
ReplyDelete